Sunday, 2 June 2013

Response to Ntate Lefifi Tladi







Thobela Ntate Tladi,

Leina lame ke Thabiso, wa ga Nkoana.  Ke Sedingwane, Makolometsha, ngwan’a noka e kgolo, Peba. I am a self-proclaimed wordsmith who recently won the best poetry performance at the Zabalaza theatre festival ya Baxter Theatre as well as the slam poetry competition ya Slipnet held in Stellenbosch.  I have been writing and reciting poetry for the better part of the last fifteen years of my life.  I have a blog (thabisonkoana.blogspot.com) in which I post some of my poetry and any essays I write for college purposes, which I deem to be of benefit for the general public – all about topics in music, musicology or ethnomusicology.  I am the eldest son of a man and woman who are workers, blue collar, from Hammanskraal and Kagiso respectively: a man and a woman who played important roles (directly and indirectly) in the political liberation of Azania.  I was born in Kagiso myself and raised in Diepkloof. 
It is very important that you know exactly who I am so as to be able to contextualise this letter and my work. 

I recently read an article on the Sowetan Live website titled, “Today's SA protest poets have no ideology, says Tladi.”  Suffice it to say, I was extremely offended, as is made apparent by my comment on said site.  The first question I wish ask is this, who are these protest poets of which you speak so scathingly?  Certainly someone of your stature knows better than to make such sweeping statements about such a diverse group of people.  Especially being from an era where generalisations led to one of the most inhumane laws the world has ever seen.
Second, what exactly is it that you would like to see happening with poets and poetry of our age?  (I use the word our very specifically, as opposed to yours)  Instead of berating the youth for their alleged lack of direction or unifying ideology, as an elder, you should rather suggest what we could and should be doing.  This, of course, does not mean that we will take what you say and blindly run with it, rather, it would be a chance for us to discuss and debate various options and ideas. 
I have always had one complaint about your generation.  You all went out and did a vigorous toyi toyi for the liberation of this wonderful country, came home for your colour film plate of food, watched the news, read the paper and went to bed.  Only so you can do it all again the next day.  The very children and youth that your were apparently fighting for were never sat down and guided as to what you expect of us when this freedom is won.  Then your generation has the audacity to moan about this or that.  Is it or was it our duty to educate ourselves as to the best way forward after that now famous negotiated settlement?  Clearly it was and that is what we did.  We are in the process of building a nation, a world that you might not understand, but will have to accept. 
It is indeed the nature of life for older generations to complain about the following generation.  I see it in ourselves by how much we complain about, for example, the music teens are listening to these days.  So I am not surprised by your utterances.
The third point I’d like to address is your assumptions.  Why do you assume Black Consciousness does not inspire us?  What makes you feel we aren’t writing stories about ourselves in an effort to “…teach about ourselves…?”  Not being sure if you were indeed being vague or if the article was perhaps badly edited, you have said a lot of not much.  All you’ve done is speak about yourself and your generation.  As shining examples of what it means to be an artist or a poet.  Not once did you take the opportunity to possibly research or analyse our situation as the youth movement.
Lastly, I personally pride myself in making sure that my poetry not only highlights problems, but also offers up possible solutions to said predicaments.  Many of my peers have a very clear and definite idea of where we want this country to go.  We use our various talents to propagate ideologies and ideas that we believe will best suit our communities.  If you’re wondering what those are, you must ask. 
You speak about us in such a patronising and condescending manner.  Like we’re ignorant gold diggers who are hungry for television fame.  Indeed, many who have joined the ranks of poets in this country are in it for the wrong reasons, like the hype.  It’s very cool to be a poet these days, you get the girls, a little bit of underground fame, people think your “deep” and it’s all a fun ride from one stage to another. 
With that being said; do not for a second think that we are all that way inclined.  Do you think being a protest poet in this day and age is any easier?  You’ve seen what happens to artists like Ayanda Mbulu or journalists like Mzilikazi wa Afrika, you know that people are being assassinated in the North West and KwaZulu-Natal, so just because the dangers you faced were more apparent, don’t diminish those that face us.  We are very brave, if not more so, because we have to protest against our “heroes.”  Write protest against people like Nelson Mandela, an international hero.  I am sure you can admit how that cannot be easy, particularly in Azania.  We have to protest against multi-national corporations whose capital could help improve the lives of many a youth of Azania.  In writing and performing such works, we run the risk of alienating said capital.
As for this Mothibe fellow, the less said the better.
Please uncle, don’t paint us with the same brush.  E, re na le diphoso, empa ga re tshwane.
Again I point you to a poem I wrote some years ago that speaks to this very issue, http://thabisonkoana.blogspot.com/2013/02/for-poets.html. 
I hope this letter finds you well and wish to end by thanking you for giving us something to think about and for the amazing contribution you’ve made to the love of our lives, poetry.
Sincerely,

#Wordsmith

No comments:

Post a Comment